{
  "schema": 1,
  "kind": "macOS_common734_write_save_as_native_failure",
  "scope": "Real failure before first save in native write-save-reopen; no DOCX/MWX/copy reopen accepted.",
  "failure": {
    "scenario": "write-save-reopen",
    "status": "FAIL",
    "method": "native_interaction",
    "attempt_id": "macos-write-save-attempt1",
    "continuous_attempt": true,
    "candidate_source_commit": "73400052f71be976f66ca246a5df7bd35e90de9e",
    "candidate_source_tree_sha256": "a9522c9e73410b1a3e2ff39784e0ff395ef29198b9d79845ab15e167ab22dd06",
    "candidate_manifest_sha256": "1ce3dbcc00ad859aaebf47235db1c71411fe01b66111925995e0485d3acb752f",
    "qa_start_commit": "7ae6fd0794903769c442c65d87addf1dd98b48d3",
    "qa_finalize_commit": "c07a23ff3ecad412d143d80f154c33b11c042b7e",
    "qa_native_file_sha256": "8de9b07f71cf99051bac3be11fbd79d38354febcd793235c909a774e051a7200",
    "profile": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/native-b2-common734/macos-write-save-attempt1/profile",
    "runtime": [
      {
        "role": "Write",
        "pid": 90179,
        "ppid": 1,
        "command": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-core/MeridianOffice/target/common-candidate-73400052/work/first-extracted/MOffice-development/MOffice Write.app/Contents/MacOS/meridian-write --size 1200x800 --ax-dump",
        "executable": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-core/MeridianOffice/target/common-candidate-73400052/work/first-extracted/MOffice-development/MOffice Write.app/Contents/MacOS/meridian-write",
        "sha256": "35918960701eaf055c741818f8a5d2973139f478c0d777dfc29b27f31a564004"
      }
    ],
    "observed_at": "2026-10-08T00:52:03.229Z",
    "reason": "Visible Save As routes to placeholder instead of a real save dialog; no file can be chosen through that route. Backstage actions are absent from OS accessibility tree.",
    "failed_step": {
      "action": "Native click visible Save As sidebar at original OS capture pixel200,488",
      "actual": "Save As page shows Появится вместе с моделью документа и кодеками (фаза 1).; OS AX contains only window controls/menubar.",
      "evidence": [
        "save-as-selected.jpg",
        "save-as-selected-ax.txt",
        "cua-actions.jsonl"
      ]
    },
    "checks": {
      "created_synthetic_text": true,
      "save_as_offered_real_dialog": false,
      "docx_reopened": "NOT_RUN",
      "mwx_reopened": "NOT_RUN",
      "copy_reopened": "NOT_RUN",
      "original_unchanged": "NOT_RUN_no_saved_original"
    },
    "source_boundary": {
      "ui_app_rs_sha256": "1ea1584cd48445e4649fe9b5077436b9015a3fbeb154ff45b27c94980a9b33d1",
      "exactly_matches_candidate734_source": true,
      "stub_sections": [
        2,
        3
      ]
    },
    "frames": [
      {
        "path": "backstage-before-coordinate.jpg",
        "bytes": 171790,
        "sha256": "d0b1e786e60da31546f8b248bb393496e2dc5fa9dfa8d03af4421cb21e39f5f2",
        "decoded_size": [
          2400,
          1600
        ],
        "origin": "original_CUA_OS_JPEG"
      },
      {
        "path": "file-backstage.jpg",
        "bytes": 171851,
        "sha256": "12d645b7e978f261425df876d3be3464a101c8303ac4b8768baa162f0e6d00f1",
        "decoded_size": [
          2400,
          1600
        ],
        "origin": "original_CUA_OS_JPEG"
      },
      {
        "path": "save-as-page.jpg",
        "bytes": 170943,
        "sha256": "6a30cee35ff8c154dfe5382e1aa1da43d5f591a883338d35e82b8b41e0b36d22",
        "decoded_size": [
          2400,
          1600
        ],
        "origin": "original_CUA_OS_JPEG"
      },
      {
        "path": "save-as-selected.jpg",
        "bytes": 131116,
        "sha256": "304df653db1df6f5ebbde35d18cce134f43a0ff650d88e69cb45176b4741db93",
        "decoded_size": [
          2400,
          1600
        ],
        "origin": "original_CUA_OS_JPEG"
      }
    ],
    "files_saved": 0,
    "reviewer": "Codex session B; direct original native OS screenshot/AX inspection",
    "limitations": [
      "No PASS inferred from headless/debug APIs.",
      "No saved file or reopen/PDF acceptance; failure occurs before first save.",
      "Cmd+Shift+S was a diagnostic wrong shortcut for this product (ToggleStyles); it is not the cause of the observed visible Save As stub.",
      "First coordinate used incorrect logical scaling and hit Create; preserved as harness mapping error. Correct OS pixel action selected Save As.",
      "Menu Escape input did not dismiss native menu; exposed AX Cancel did. No repeated unchanged retries or permission changes.",
      "Native input is OS automation on physical Mac; user IME/reader/hardware keyboard unverified."
    ]
  },
  "artifacts": [
    {
      "path": "macos-write-save-attempt1/attempt.json",
      "origin_path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/native-b2-common734/macos-write-save-attempt1/attempt.json",
      "bytes": 5327,
      "sha256": "4753404318883475b18d5c87026903f5405e8753046bfa6711d77b6ea5befa3b"
    },
    {
      "path": "macos-write-save-attempt1/backstage-before-coordinate-ax.txt",
      "origin_path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/native-b2-common734/macos-write-save-attempt1/backstage-before-coordinate-ax.txt",
      "bytes": 483,
      "sha256": "b43f6725feb5211fccdca241058491b96411957a4a02b5e5e980122d3979e28a"
    },
    {
      "path": "macos-write-save-attempt1/backstage-before-coordinate.jpg",
      "origin_path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/native-b2-common734/macos-write-save-attempt1/backstage-before-coordinate.jpg",
      "bytes": 171790,
      "sha256": "d0b1e786e60da31546f8b248bb393496e2dc5fa9dfa8d03af4421cb21e39f5f2"
    },
    {
      "path": "macos-write-save-attempt1/candidate-app-source.rs",
      "origin_path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/native-b2-common734/macos-write-save-attempt1/candidate-app-source.rs",
      "bytes": 146712,
      "sha256": "1ea1584cd48445e4649fe9b5077436b9015a3fbeb154ff45b27c94980a9b33d1"
    },
    {
      "path": "macos-write-save-attempt1/cua-actions.jsonl",
      "origin_path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/native-b2-common734/macos-write-save-attempt1/cua-actions.jsonl",
      "bytes": 4135,
      "sha256": "b45ddaa1d133b7b1f5e0a39459f9555c79c9ba6a37d6dac13e470630bd117d96"
    },
    {
      "path": "macos-write-save-attempt1/failure-observation.json",
      "origin_path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/native-b2-common734/macos-write-save-attempt1/failure-observation.json",
      "bytes": 4336,
      "sha256": "edc1360cdbc58740cb605b1d250126ad8f743b1a6a1da4e0182e74b4617b85e7"
    },
    {
      "path": "macos-write-save-attempt1/file-backstage-ax.txt",
      "origin_path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/native-b2-common734/macos-write-save-attempt1/file-backstage-ax.txt",
      "bytes": 483,
      "sha256": "b43f6725feb5211fccdca241058491b96411957a4a02b5e5e980122d3979e28a"
    },
    {
      "path": "macos-write-save-attempt1/file-backstage.jpg",
      "origin_path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/native-b2-common734/macos-write-save-attempt1/file-backstage.jpg",
      "bytes": 171851,
      "sha256": "12d645b7e978f261425df876d3be3464a101c8303ac4b8768baa162f0e6d00f1"
    },
    {
      "path": "macos-write-save-attempt1/file-menu-cancelled-ax.txt",
      "origin_path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/native-b2-common734/macos-write-save-attempt1/file-menu-cancelled-ax.txt",
      "bytes": 5725,
      "sha256": "b06da3b813e15ae068d6f182d9e1bcb15057c6dece3c7fdbbea863b7e0455ec8"
    },
    {
      "path": "macos-write-save-attempt1/native-file-menu-ax.txt",
      "origin_path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/native-b2-common734/macos-write-save-attempt1/native-file-menu-ax.txt",
      "bytes": 556,
      "sha256": "bf52ad4823add199dffd7149d017ffd358e7adba807920962f91f56f90cfdb63"
    },
    {
      "path": "macos-write-save-attempt1/original-text.txt",
      "origin_path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/native-b2-common734/macos-write-save-attempt1/original-text.txt",
      "bytes": 140,
      "sha256": "02083da96af3dc83cdd1b6525986ef6a0ae114d662fed4fd57e6d1e47c59d3ed"
    },
    {
      "path": "macos-write-save-attempt1/palette-closed-ax.txt",
      "origin_path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/native-b2-common734/macos-write-save-attempt1/palette-closed-ax.txt",
      "bytes": 5725,
      "sha256": "b06da3b813e15ae068d6f182d9e1bcb15057c6dece3c7fdbbea863b7e0455ec8"
    },
    {
      "path": "macos-write-save-attempt1/palette-open-ax.txt",
      "origin_path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/native-b2-common734/macos-write-save-attempt1/palette-open-ax.txt",
      "bytes": 1438,
      "sha256": "4a76fff4f2a9c11ea3cd5ee60bd0756b70e97feacb9ab1ab48dc1ec044a79215"
    },
    {
      "path": "macos-write-save-attempt1/save-as-dialog-ax.txt",
      "origin_path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/native-b2-common734/macos-write-save-attempt1/save-as-dialog-ax.txt",
      "bytes": 5725,
      "sha256": "b06da3b813e15ae068d6f182d9e1bcb15057c6dece3c7fdbbea863b7e0455ec8"
    },
    {
      "path": "macos-write-save-attempt1/save-as-page-ax.txt",
      "origin_path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/native-b2-common734/macos-write-save-attempt1/save-as-page-ax.txt",
      "bytes": 483,
      "sha256": "b43f6725feb5211fccdca241058491b96411957a4a02b5e5e980122d3979e28a"
    },
    {
      "path": "macos-write-save-attempt1/save-as-page.jpg",
      "origin_path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/native-b2-common734/macos-write-save-attempt1/save-as-page.jpg",
      "bytes": 170943,
      "sha256": "6a30cee35ff8c154dfe5382e1aa1da43d5f591a883338d35e82b8b41e0b36d22"
    },
    {
      "path": "macos-write-save-attempt1/save-as-selected-ax.txt",
      "origin_path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/native-b2-common734/macos-write-save-attempt1/save-as-selected-ax.txt",
      "bytes": 483,
      "sha256": "b43f6725feb5211fccdca241058491b96411957a4a02b5e5e980122d3979e28a"
    },
    {
      "path": "macos-write-save-attempt1/save-as-selected.jpg",
      "origin_path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/native-b2-common734/macos-write-save-attempt1/save-as-selected.jpg",
      "bytes": 131116,
      "sha256": "304df653db1df6f5ebbde35d18cce134f43a0ff650d88e69cb45176b4741db93"
    },
    {
      "path": "macos-write-save-attempt1/write-created-ax.txt",
      "origin_path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/native-b2-common734/macos-write-save-attempt1/write-created-ax.txt",
      "bytes": 5725,
      "sha256": "b06da3b813e15ae068d6f182d9e1bcb15057c6dece3c7fdbbea863b7e0455ec8"
    },
    {
      "path": "macos-write-save-attempt1/write-initial-ax.txt",
      "origin_path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/native-b2-common734/macos-write-save-attempt1/write-initial-ax.txt",
      "bytes": 5561,
      "sha256": "8b649130b793ba3c82645ef0d994c50da88b6f1409c730f4b6bddccbcee0bd37"
    },
    {
      "path": "macos-write-save-attempt1/write-returned-ax.txt",
      "origin_path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/native-b2-common734/macos-write-save-attempt1/write-returned-ax.txt",
      "bytes": 556,
      "sha256": "bf52ad4823add199dffd7149d017ffd358e7adba807920962f91f56f90cfdb63"
    },
    {
      "path": "macos-write-save-attempt1/write.log",
      "origin_path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/native-b2-common734/macos-write-save-attempt1/write.log",
      "bytes": 718,
      "sha256": "2375db82cd403d500213f52d908f84c0fdee984b5c52f54d0f1387ac0aac8983"
    },
    {
      "path": "launch_write_save_attempt.py",
      "origin_path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/native-b2-common734/launch_write_save_attempt.py",
      "bytes": 2299,
      "sha256": "6aa8a7b568cb34e8a2e53c884d3177cb6a2bbc6d6d607faf0e3f6e95d9d7980b"
    },
    {
      "path": "export_write_save_failure.py",
      "origin_path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/native-b2-common734/export_write_save_failure.py",
      "bytes": 4414,
      "sha256": "657ae6793c13053f27007ce8cdabfdd94990a2424cfe9a84ca7c0cb43f2292fb"
    }
  ],
  "canonical_matrix_validation": "NOT_ASSEMBLED_for_failed_partial_case; this failure receipt does not impersonate a successful native gate.",
  "observed_union_candidate734": {
    "PASS_rows": [
      "macOS/hub-open-write",
      "macOS/hub-open-sheets"
    ],
    "FAIL_rows": [
      "macOS/write-save-reopen"
    ],
    "remaining_rows": 45
  },
  "limitations": [
    "The two PASS rows have separate canonical runs/receipts; none of their assertions is used for this failed scenario.",
    "Source734 failure is preserved after code fix; retest requires a different exact binary/candidate identity.",
    "Private profile/nonce excluded from immutable evidence archive.",
    "Corrected coordinate mapping and mistaken shortcut remain explicitly logged as harness diagnostics."
  ],
  "export": {
    "path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/native-b2-common734/write-save-734-failure-evidence/write-save-734-failure-evidence.tar.gz",
    "bytes": 379293,
    "sha256": "0a769759bbde43eb2a22606ee3061257dc2a72472c9ba0dbd75b13709b2c2e4f",
    "file_count": 24
  }
}
