{
  "schema": 1,
  "kind": "native-platform-two-attempt-review",
  "date": "2026-10-08",
  "product_release": false,
  "qa_tooling_commit": "9660099727c915ab93e4fbe7df6faa01562f7852",
  "artifact_store": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/platform-native-recent-20261008",
  "candidate": {
    "source_commit": "bb9ee56da5bb5990ee5525b5d0d762915d536da3",
    "source_tree_sha256": "c3b2a5dd77a73b3ce8759f0526c2887968a6acd3095a7340226f1c36c6543864",
    "manifest_sha256": "33ab0958892edc4fa9e34033e7069b41fdd8365ce11de2381270948f8381bfba",
    "binaries": [
      {
        "path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/platform-candidate-fixed-20261008/work/first-extracted/MOffice-development/MOffice Hub.app/Contents/MacOS/meridian-hub",
        "sha256": "730540f5cc2382d80207c5bea021d1e01be2f8d2d45100a7f522e0ded088c492",
        "app": "Hub"
      },
      {
        "path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/platform-candidate-fixed-20261008/work/first-extracted/MOffice-development/MOffice Hub.app/Contents/MacOS/meridian-broker",
        "sha256": "4283b67305f547f957afefa34e88a68fa207900d46139ec5bcec64ed9b6ff3fe",
        "app": "Hub"
      },
      {
        "path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/platform-candidate-fixed-20261008/work/first-extracted/MOffice-development/MOffice Write.app/Contents/MacOS/meridian-write",
        "sha256": "5e55c1a377248eb5138ac6ec71ca7a8260e387f64041463662cbe994fdf3d591",
        "app": "Write"
      },
      {
        "path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/platform-candidate-fixed-20261008/work/first-extracted/MOffice-development/MOffice Write.app/Contents/MacOS/meridian-broker",
        "sha256": "4283b67305f547f957afefa34e88a68fa207900d46139ec5bcec64ed9b6ff3fe",
        "app": "Write"
      },
      {
        "path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/platform-candidate-fixed-20261008/work/first-extracted/MOffice-development/MOffice Sheets.app/Contents/MacOS/meridian-sheets",
        "sha256": "50fc907f609b5b7f450d81b6377aeb827271f76f0a06c92f89595e3cdc12e411",
        "app": "Sheets"
      },
      {
        "path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/platform-candidate-fixed-20261008/work/first-extracted/MOffice-development/MOffice Sheets.app/Contents/MacOS/meridian-broker",
        "sha256": "4283b67305f547f957afefa34e88a68fa207900d46139ec5bcec64ed9b6ff3fe",
        "app": "Sheets"
      },
      {
        "path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/platform-candidate-fixed-20261008/work/first-extracted/MOffice-development/MOffice Quick Access.app/Contents/MacOS/meridian-menubar",
        "sha256": "b217f52407eb1ae285d983c6181eabca4a132edf71014338844085de1c2851e1",
        "app": "Quick Access"
      },
      {
        "path": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/platform-candidate-fixed-20261008/work/first-extracted/MOffice-development/MOffice Quick Access.app/Contents/MacOS/meridian-broker",
        "sha256": "4283b67305f547f957afefa34e88a68fa207900d46139ec5bcec64ed9b6ff3fe",
        "app": "Quick Access"
      }
    ]
  },
  "host": {
    "platform": "macOS",
    "release": "27.0.0",
    "os_version": "macOS-27.0-arm64-arm-64bit",
    "architecture": "arm64",
    "kind": "physical",
    "python": "3.12.14"
  },
  "gate": {
    "overall_status": "BLOCKED",
    "issues": [],
    "counts": {
      "NOT_RUN": 47,
      "FAIL": 0,
      "BLOCKED": 0,
      "PASS": 1
    },
    "note": "Smoke/AX/IME injection/PDF CLI results never promote required native interaction scenarios.",
    "smoke_integrity_issues": [],
    "smoke_failures": []
  },
  "reviewed_scenario": {
    "id": "hub-open-write",
    "platform": "macOS",
    "status": "PASS",
    "artifacts": [
      {
        "path": "attempt-1/write-open-os.jpg",
        "role": "capture",
        "sha256": "c307f76067b088c9864cbf11294e9cc99031d4d81f64aa3f924e18450489db40",
        "bytes": 319854
      },
      {
        "path": "attempt-1/write-open.ax.txt",
        "role": "accessibility",
        "sha256": "eb912ba02c5407ee38786cb280df07fe2c436d0fa47e992eda3a0875c5d1e893",
        "bytes": 6326
      },
      {
        "path": "attempt-1/native-processes.json",
        "role": "runtime",
        "sha256": "e3e6d122940018bb11c12f5fd4790e3e1a17c7c14e939cd65824f9a6acaf6621",
        "bytes": 1128
      },
      {
        "path": "attempt-1/hub-launch.json",
        "role": "invocation",
        "sha256": "dbb81663ce4890999640e4acbea450e2042ee03a3cf44f01e2c7eb67e472ead9",
        "bytes": 461
      },
      {
        "path": "attempt-1/hub-write-actions.json",
        "role": "prior_actions",
        "sha256": "3832916b6711b9f1d616d44352eab57f6e6151c06148e3a629ac8f7d9f1c65e5",
        "bytes": 1230
      },
      {
        "path": "home/Documents/native-letter.docx",
        "role": "input",
        "sha256": "a9de831b5c14e47ca8195d49e622793870efdd2dcf5459e1aafa622424e016b7",
        "bytes": 1447
      },
      {
        "path": "hub-open.ax.txt",
        "role": "accessibility",
        "sha256": "3842ffd386d2c1e1a30fc7b62391b9c8446391902f34f56746f4bf32b9a760a4",
        "bytes": 3382
      },
      {
        "path": "hub-main.ax.txt",
        "role": "accessibility",
        "sha256": "3842ffd386d2c1e1a30fc7b62391b9c8446391902f34f56746f4bf32b9a760a4",
        "bytes": 3382
      },
      {
        "path": "hub-welcome.ax.txt",
        "role": "accessibility",
        "sha256": "c364f6086f77b1eb1c263152f47292e192d4d245be3a453c1ee09a16e0745f2c",
        "bytes": 750
      },
      {
        "path": "native-processes.json",
        "role": "runtime",
        "sha256": "42ccd1d8b7d93807f471114b496abf398db098ee335b5c6bc587ee041b783174",
        "bytes": 1052
      },
      {
        "path": "native-status.json",
        "role": "runtime",
        "sha256": "360306b56646afba258fef135ab7845312cd920e2ec1ce6303b98bd84809563e",
        "bytes": 1128
      },
      {
        "path": "hub-runtime.log",
        "role": "runtime",
        "sha256": "3150aa40a2c3681506e92722fdffb236eaf92d5be09ef59818b612c36f8f6433",
        "bytes": 387
      },
      {
        "path": "hub-launch.json",
        "role": "invocation",
        "sha256": "128114cc291efc839458537091640429a21d51d89cf398bfb67a5ab5e50d8634",
        "bytes": 464
      },
      {
        "path": "profile/recent.tsv",
        "role": "recent_store",
        "sha256": "3daf3405901fee830452865ef0f7dd80299d3c10f27b0625b0df06f9afc390de",
        "bytes": 208
      },
      {
        "path": "provenance.json",
        "role": "provenance",
        "sha256": "45cba6c94c261f15acd81f79a1e670551c3cc9e43cf66fe4c809de08721eba8a",
        "bytes": 6144
      },
      {
        "path": "actions.json",
        "role": "actions",
        "sha256": "85582b4ec528f1721cf031a105efe0533b9c2d7678e49d665e13dae84223f78b",
        "bytes": 1584
      },
      {
        "path": "observation.json",
        "role": "observation",
        "sha256": "c42919892844ca879969fcd8b1ef6fd8a5ddacf85dbe5f6cfc8376b64709e64f",
        "bytes": 1780
      }
    ],
    "reason": "Reviewed assertions across two native attempts of the same immutable bb9ee56d manifest and identical synthetic DOCX; original Write JPEG/AX and fresh Hub Recents AX. This is not the integrated core candidate.",
    "method": "native_interaction"
  },
  "observation": {
    "scenario": "hub-open-write",
    "platform": "macOS",
    "candidate_manifest_sha256": "33ab0958892edc4fa9e34033e7069b41fdd8365ce11de2381270948f8381bfba",
    "method": "native_interaction",
    "capture_origin": "os_window_capture",
    "reviewer": "Codex session 2, CUA and original OS JPEG visual review",
    "observed_at": "2026-10-07T22:26:56.444631+00:00",
    "evidence_scope": "Two real native attempts of the same immutable packaged candidate and identical synthetic fixture. The Write JPEG is from attempt 1, not a new screenshot of attempt 2. No native acceptance is claimed for the later integrated core candidate.",
    "checks": {
      "correct_editor": {
        "passed": true,
        "actual": "Both native attempts use the same archived manifest; Hub broker launches the exact packaged Write with the synthetic DOCX argument.",
        "evidence": [
          "native-processes.json",
          "attempt-1/native-processes.json",
          "provenance.json"
        ]
      },
      "same_document": {
        "passed": true,
        "actual": "Attempt 1 original OS JPEG and AX display native-letter.docx, page 1/1 and its three expected paragraphs. Attempt 2 fixture bytes are identical. This JPEG is explicitly retained from attempt 1.",
        "evidence": [
          "attempt-1/write-open-os.jpg",
          "attempt-1/write-open.ax.txt",
          "home/Documents/native-letter.docx",
          "provenance.json"
        ]
      },
      "recent_entry": {
        "passed": true,
        "actual": "Fresh native Hub AX after Return in attempt 2 displays native-letter.docx in Недавние with pin/remove actions and first page preview 1/1. recent.tsv is additional disk evidence.",
        "evidence": [
          "hub-open.ax.txt",
          "actions.json",
          "profile/recent.tsv"
        ]
      }
    }
  },
  "provenance": {
    "candidate_manifest_sha256": "33ab0958892edc4fa9e34033e7069b41fdd8365ce11de2381270948f8381bfba",
    "candidate_matches_both_attempts": true,
    "fixture_sha256": "a9de831b5c14e47ca8195d49e622793870efdd2dcf5459e1aafa622424e016b7",
    "fixture_bytes_match_both_attempts": true,
    "attempt_1": {
      "run": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/platform-native-fixed-20261008",
      "role": "original Write OS JPEG and AX verify fixture content",
      "original_capture_sha256": "c307f76067b088c9864cbf11294e9cc99031d4d81f64aa3f924e18450489db40",
      "id": "platform-native-fixed-20261008",
      "profile": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/platform-native-fixed-20261008/profile",
      "home": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/platform-native-fixed-20261008/home",
      "source_commit": "bb9ee56da5bb5990ee5525b5d0d762915d536da3",
      "manifest_sha256": "33ab0958892edc4fa9e34033e7069b41fdd8365ce11de2381270948f8381bfba",
      "fixture_sha256": "a9de831b5c14e47ca8195d49e622793870efdd2dcf5459e1aafa622424e016b7",
      "processes": {
        "observed_at": "2026-10-07T22:14:51.847978+00:00",
        "processes": [
          {
            "pid": 46885,
            "process": "46885  1095 /Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/platform-candidate-fixed-20261008/work/first-extracted/MOffice-development/MOffice Hub.app/Contents/MacOS/meridian-hub --quit-after 300000 --ax-dump --size 1200x800"
          },
          {
            "pid": 51256,
            "process": "51256 46907 /Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/platform-candidate-fixed-20261008/work/first-extracted/MOffice-development/MOffice Write.app/Contents/MacOS/meridian-write /Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/platform-native-fixed-20261008/home/Documents/native-letter.docx"
          },
          {
            "pid": 46907,
            "process": "46907 46885 /Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/platform-candidate-fixed-20261008/work/first-extracted/MOffice-development/MOffice Hub.app/Contents/MacOS/meridian-broker --profile /Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/platform-native-fixed-20261008/profile"
          }
        ]
      },
      "capture": {
        "artifact": "attempt-1/write-open-os.jpg",
        "origin": "os_window_capture",
        "capture_attempt_id": "platform-native-fixed-20261008",
        "sha256": "c307f76067b088c9864cbf11294e9cc99031d4d81f64aa3f924e18450489db40"
      }
    },
    "attempt_2": {
      "run": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/platform-native-recent-20261008",
      "role": "fresh native Hub Return, broker Write spawn and Hub Recents AX after opening",
      "id": "platform-native-recent-20261008",
      "profile": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/platform-native-recent-20261008/profile",
      "home": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/platform-native-recent-20261008/home",
      "source_commit": "bb9ee56da5bb5990ee5525b5d0d762915d536da3",
      "manifest_sha256": "33ab0958892edc4fa9e34033e7069b41fdd8365ce11de2381270948f8381bfba",
      "fixture_sha256": "a9de831b5c14e47ca8195d49e622793870efdd2dcf5459e1aafa622424e016b7",
      "processes": [
        {
          "pid": 70769,
          "ppid": 1095,
          "command": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/platform-candidate-fixed-20261008/work/first-extracted/MOffice-development/MOffice Hub.app/Contents/MacOS/meridian-hub --quit-after 180000 --size 1200x800 --ax-dump"
        },
        {
          "pid": 70803,
          "ppid": 70769,
          "command": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/platform-candidate-fixed-20261008/work/first-extracted/MOffice-development/MOffice Hub.app/Contents/MacOS/meridian-broker --profile /Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/platform-native-recent-20261008/profile"
        },
        {
          "pid": 71953,
          "ppid": 70803,
          "command": "/Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/platform-candidate-fixed-20261008/work/first-extracted/MOffice-development/MOffice Write.app/Contents/MacOS/meridian-write /Users/amo/.codex/worktrees/moffice-platform/MeridianOffice/target/platform-native-recent-20261008/home/Documents/native-letter.docx"
        }
      ]
    },
    "review_scope": "Two real native attempts of the same immutable packaged candidate and identical synthetic fixture. The Write JPEG is from attempt 1, not a new screenshot of attempt 2. No native acceptance is claimed for the later integrated core candidate.",
    "assertion_origins": {
      "correct_editor": [
        "platform-native-fixed-20261008",
        "platform-native-recent-20261008"
      ],
      "same_document": [
        "platform-native-fixed-20261008"
      ],
      "recent_entry": [
        "platform-native-recent-20261008"
      ]
    },
    "criterion_review": {
      "catalog": "qa/native/scenarios.json",
      "scenario": "hub-open-write",
      "checks": [
        "correct_editor",
        "same_document",
        "recent_entry"
      ],
      "roles": [
        "capture",
        "actions",
        "input",
        "runtime"
      ],
      "interpretation": "The existing scenario requires opening from Hub, reviewing content in Write and an entry in Recents for one immutable candidate. It does not state a continuous-run or fresh-final-capture requirement. Acceptance here reviews those three assertions across two native attempts with the same manifest and byte-identical fixture; it does not claim one uninterrupted end-to-end run.",
      "review_basis": "Original OS Write pixels and native AX prove same_document in attempt 1; actual native Return and broker process receipts prove correct_editor; fresh native Hub AX after Return proves recent_entry in attempt 2. JSON structural PASS alone is not the review basis.",
      "remaining_required_repeat": "An uninterrupted affected scenario on the fresh integrated-core candidate remains required before common candidate acceptance."
    }
  },
  "limitations": [
    "One reviewed platform-archive row; 47 required rows NOT_RUN.",
    "No newly captured JPEG from attempt 2: ScreenCaptureKit errors remain.",
    "A fresh integrated-core candidate and affected native scenario must be repeated."
  ],
  "prior_attempt_gate": "docs/integration/evidence/platform-native-bb9ee56d.json (0 PASS / 1 BLOCKED / 47 NOT_RUN retained unchanged)"
}
